Volume : 12, Issue : 10, October – 2025
Title:
ETHICAL CHALLENGES IN PREHOSPITAL EMERGENCY CARE: A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW OF THE LITERATURE ON DECISION-MAKING IN AUSTERE ENVIRONMENTS
Authors :
Saad Sultan Saad Alamri, Ali Ahmed Saeed Alzahrani, Ahmad Thallab Mutlaq Alsharif, Abdullah Mohammed Yaseen M Almasri, Sualtan Mohammed Yassen Al Masri, Azim Mulfi L Alzibali, Obaid Amer Mouteq Alharbi, Muidh Bakeet Muidh Almabadi, Mastour Awadh Alzibali
Abstract :
Prehospital care in austere environments presents a unique set of ethical challenges that extend beyond clinical decision-making. This systematic review synthesizes the literature to identify and characterize the ethical dilemmas faced by emergency medical providers in these high-stakes settings. The analysis reveals five predominant themes: (1) triage and resource allocation under scarcity, (2) consent and patient autonomy in crisis situations, (3) determining the limits of beneficence and non-maleficence, (4) professional role integrity and moral distress, and (5) balancing duty of care with provider safety. These challenges are influenced by system-level, provider-level, and situation-level factors and have significant consequences for both patient care quality and provider well-being, including moral distress, burnout, and PTSD. The findings underscore the erosion of standard bioethical frameworks in austerity and highlight the critical need for enhanced ethics education, robust support systems, and the development of practical decision-making aids. We propose the concept of “Prehospital Ethical Resilience” as a necessary focus for future efforts aimed at supporting providers and ensuring ethically sound care in these demanding environments.
Keywords: Prehospital Ethics, Moral Distress, Austere Medicine, Resource Allocation, Emergency Medical Services
Cite This Article:
Please cite this article in press Saad Sultan Saad Alamri et al., Ethical Challenges In Prehospital Emergency Care: A Systematic Review Of The Literature On Decision-Making In Austere Environments, Indo Am. J. P. Sci, 2025; 12(10).
REFERENCES:
1. Beauchamp, T. L., & Childress, J. F. (2019). Principles of Biomedical Ethics (8th ed.). Oxford University Press.
2. Brenner, J. M., Aswegan, A. L., Vearrier, L. E., Basford, J. B., & Iserson, K. V. (2018). The ethics of real-time EMS direction: Suggested curricular content. Prehospital and disaster medicine, 33(2), 201-212.
3. Butler, P. C., Flin, R., Bearman, C., Hayes, P., Penney, G., & McLennan, J. (2024). Emergency management decision-making in a changing world: 3 key challenges. The Australian Journal of Emergency Management, 39(4), 23-32.
4. Clemency, B. M., Thompson, J. J., Tundo, G. N., & Lindstrom, H. A. (2017). Prehospital provider recognition of the need for critical care interventions in adults. Prehospital Emergency Care, 21(3), 344-350.
5. Fowler, R., Hansen, M., Vestergaard, L., & Lippert, F. (2019). Ethical decision-making in prehospital emergency care. Scandinavian Journal of Trauma, Resuscitation and Emergency Medicine, 27(1), 67.
6. Klein, K. R., Peleg, K., & Jaffe, E. (2021). Ethics in disaster medicine: A review of the literature and a call to action. Prehospital and Disaster Medicine, 36(4), 385-390.
7. Lennquist, S. (2020). Management of major accidents and disasters in the prehospital setting. British Journal of Anaesthesia, 125(1), e1-e4.
8. Li, H., Zhang, J., Zhang, N., & Zhu, B. (2025). Advancing Emergency Care With Digital Twins. JMIR aging, 8, e71777.
9. Maguire, B. J., O’Meara, P. F., Brightwell, R. F., O’Neill, B. J., & Fitzgerald, G. J. (2021). Occupational injury risk among Australian paramedics: An analysis of national data. BMJ Open, 11(11), e053834.
10. Martin, M. J., & Eckert, M. J. (2016). Difficult Triage Decisions in the Combat or Austere Environment. In Surgery During Natural Disasters, Combat, Terrorist Attacks, and Crisis Situations (pp. 47-55). Cham: Springer International Publishing.
11. Mcdowall, J., Makkink, A. W., & Jarman, K. (2023). Physical restraint within the prehospital Emergency Medical Care Environment: A scoping review. African Journal of Emergency Medicine, 13(3), 157-165.
12. Mikkelsen, S., & Lossius, H. M. (2020). Prehospital critical care: its impact and future. Current Opinion in Critical Care, 26(6), 637-644.
13. Niyonsaba, M., Nkeshimana, M., Uwitonze, J. M., Davies, J., Maine, R., Nyinawankusi, J. D. A., … & Watt, M. H. (2023). Challenges and opportunities to improve efficiency and quality of prehospital emergency care using an mHealth platform: Qualitative study in Rwanda. African Journal of Emergency Medicine, 13(4), 250-257.
14. Nordén, C., Hult, K., & Engström, A. (2021). Ambulance nurses’ experiences of facing ethical problems in emergency care. International Emergency Nursing, 57, 101015.
15. O’Connell, C., & Dowling, M. (2022). Ethical dilemmas in the prehospital setting: A scoping review. Nursing Ethics, 29(1), 220-235.
16. Pasquale, B. P. (2017). Exploring the Lived Experiences of Paramedics: Influences of Task Failure on Future Decision Making. Capella University.
17. Pasquale, B. P. (2017). Exploring the Lived Experiences of Paramedics: Influences of Task Failure on Future Decision Making. Capella University.
18. Pingree, C. S., Newberry, T. R., McMains, K. C., & Holt, G. R. (2020, December). Medical ethics in extreme and austere environments. In Hec Forum (Vol. 32, No. 4, pp. 345-356). Dordrecht: Springer Netherlands.
19. Prescott, T., May, S., Horne, S., & Barnard, E. (2022). Prehospital emergency care in a humanitarian environment: an overview of the ethical considerations. BMJ Mil Health, 168(6), 431-434.
20. Tolles, J., Toy, J., Bosson, N., Dillon, D. G., Donofrio-Odmann, J. J., Menegazzi, J. J., … & Gausche-Hill, M. (2025). The California Resuscitation Outcomes Consortium (CAL-ROC): A novel collaboration to facilitate the implementation of randomized clinical trials in the prehospital setting. Resuscitation Plus, 100992.
21. Torabi, M., Borhani, F., Abbaszadeh, A., & Atashzadeh-Shoorideh, F. (2020). Barriers to ethical decision-making for pre-hospital care professionals. Nursing ethics, 27(2), 407-418.
22. Torabi, M., Borhani, F., Abbaszadeh, A., & Atashzadeh-Shoorideh, F. (2019). Ethical decision-making based on field assessment: The experiences of prehospital personnel. Nursing ethics, 26(4), 1075-1086.